Friday, May 4, 2007

Republican's Presidential Candidates Debate

Last night was the Republican Presidential Candidates Debate from the Reagan Library.
As expected-- with a short time for all candidates to actually answer the questions and the rules set up disallowing candidates to direct questions to each other, everything was very cordial and all answers were short. I thought personally the moderators such as Chris Matthews did a fantastic job of touching on a lot of varied subjects from Iraq and Iran to taxes and immigration.

But here are my observations coming out of the first showdown leading to the 2008 nomination.

1. I wasn't aware of former Rep. Ron Paul as being considered a top 10 candidate. His performance though added some needed humor but it also proved to be the one completely dissenting voice on Iraq. He never supported the move from day 1 (whereas the other candidates criticized the Administration's handling of the war but do not support troop withdrawal).

2. It seemed to me that Rudy wasn't quite on his feet during the debate. He seemed to be defensive on answers and uncomfortable surrounded by the other candidates. He did though have a very strong stance on foreign policy especially concerning Muslim fundamentalists and the War on Terror. He mentioned his accomplishments as former NYC mayor and tried sidestepping the issues that would hurt with the Republican base, mainly concerning abortion rights.

3. Of all of the discussions concerning Iraq coming out of both political parties, the plan put forward by Senator Sam Brownback needs more attention. Instead of "stay the course" and "cut and run" sound clips-- Sen. Brownback proposes a realistic and new approach towards a successful conclusion in Iraq. He favors a political approach dividing Iraq into regional governments amongst the different ethnic regions. Also, the money Iraq earns in oil revenue would be distributed in 3 parts-- the federal government based in Baghdad for services, administration, etc., the separate state/regional governments, and then individual Iraqi households. This ensures that ALL Iraqis have a stake in ending the bloodshed and start working towards a recovery for ALL Iraqis.

This debate won't change the numbers drastically. The front-runners will remain at the top b/c of the money issue. They have more to spend and better staff and advisers to work on the media exposure. But I think this debate began to show the differences amongst the candidates. If I had to choose one big winner I think it would have to be a tie between Brownback and McCain. McCain looked strong and put forward a traditional Republican agenda-- strong foreign policy and reigning in spending and pork. Brownback gained much needed exposure and put forward the best argument yet on resolving the Iraq issue. As for losers, I didn't see any.

No comments: