In recent weeks the issue concerning the U.S. debt ceiling has taken center stage. Whether this show down develops into a Democratic President vs. Republican Congress type battle (ala 1996 Clinton-Gingrich) will depend a lot on the next month or so. We have heard from the main stream media and Obama officials on why this really is a no-brainer. We absolutely have to raise the debt ceiling. They predict government failure and financial Armageddon if the Republicans in the House take a firm stand. But let's take a closer look at this issue.
First, is an article by D.W. MacKenzie on the Mises website, The Budget Mess: Time to Get Serious. MacKenzie makes many valid points but the thrust of his argument is simply this-- WE WONT DEFAULT IF WE REFUSE TO RAISE THE CEILING! It's an old tactic used by both parties where you scare your opposition into submission or at least a tacit compromise to accomplish your goal. In fact going back to the last years of the George W. Bush era through now, our fiscal discipline in Washington has gone from laughable to just plain ignoring basic economic common sense. In years past, all financial backbone has disappeared from Congress and the President and debt ceilings are raised on whims and spending continues to escalate to alarming levels. Why this happens is simple. Congress is elected by the people. The people grow fat and accustomed to government programs and handouts. So these officials have incentives to print more money, spend more money, and ignore long term public interest-- financial stability. But back to the debt ceiling. The Treasury Dept has not already spent the money that the debt ceiling is meant to control. It's simply set a trajectory level for forecasting purposes. So by holding firm and refusing to raise that ceiling, we basically force Congress and Obama's hand. We simply alter their spending whims and wants.
But more than the financial jargon that gets passed around for why we can't or can raise the debt ceiling, it is a moral issue as to why we shouldn't. It's dishonest for Congress to continue to approve budgets and programs that are beyond our means to pay for. We can only spend out in government programs and agencies what the Treasury brings in via tax receipts. It would appear to be a simply Econ 101 lesson. Surprisingly- this is lost on Geithner, Obama, and others who follow Keynesian basic precepts. Political self-interest should not outweigh long term financial stability of the U.S. Our leaders have known for decades that the entitlement programs that were enacted during FDR and then in LBJ periods were not doable over the long term unless changes were formulated. Entitlement under-funding to go along with an outrageous federal debt is a combination that will only injure the U.S credit market and force even more painful concessions later down the road. We have an opportunity now to be straight with Americans regardless of how they take it. Let's hope the debt ceiling issue forces that debate out into the open.
political insights
insights on current events in the political world-- people, events, topics, etc..
Monday, May 9, 2011
Wednesday, February 17, 2010
Budget Reform
This report published by the Peterson-Pew Commission on Budget Reform brings to the forefront, once again, the dangers America faces if policymakers continue to postpone tough budgetary decisions. It is no longer a matter of scoring political points with constituencies or pleasing a financial backer by appeasing a special interest. Budget reform is an issue that should concern all taxpaying citizens of this country. Unfortunately it is much easier to show up at the local polling location and vote and then forget about things than to actively work to change the status quo and the public's apathy.
First of all, budget crises can spiral quickly out of control. Without adopting responsible actions towards our deficit and debt, as the article touches on, the government will need to borrow further, pay more interest, and possibly lead to currency crisis. Already, way too much of our public debt is owed to foreign investors. If they begin to come calling on their investments our fiscal situation will go from bad to terrifyingly awful. But a non partisan approach borrowing from both major parties can be a crucial first step towards stabilizing the situation.
Right now, the two parties avoid the issue of tax increases and focus instead of economic recovery at the domestic level. What is clear is that neither party's approach leads to where we need to be. Instead a hodge podge of tax reform and spending reforms need to be discussed. Government bailouts and stimulus packages only added to the dire situation. Those should be erased along with reforming the entitelment programs. None of this is possible while pandering for votes. At the cost of losing elections, our leaders should look at areas where taxes may have to be raised, areas where govt. programs axed, govt. departments be scaled down, and discretionary spending held in check. None of these options are popular but popularity doesn't restore a balanced budget or put our fiscal house back in order.
First of all, budget crises can spiral quickly out of control. Without adopting responsible actions towards our deficit and debt, as the article touches on, the government will need to borrow further, pay more interest, and possibly lead to currency crisis. Already, way too much of our public debt is owed to foreign investors. If they begin to come calling on their investments our fiscal situation will go from bad to terrifyingly awful. But a non partisan approach borrowing from both major parties can be a crucial first step towards stabilizing the situation.
Right now, the two parties avoid the issue of tax increases and focus instead of economic recovery at the domestic level. What is clear is that neither party's approach leads to where we need to be. Instead a hodge podge of tax reform and spending reforms need to be discussed. Government bailouts and stimulus packages only added to the dire situation. Those should be erased along with reforming the entitelment programs. None of this is possible while pandering for votes. At the cost of losing elections, our leaders should look at areas where taxes may have to be raised, areas where govt. programs axed, govt. departments be scaled down, and discretionary spending held in check. None of these options are popular but popularity doesn't restore a balanced budget or put our fiscal house back in order.
Wednesday, December 23, 2009
State of the GOP
Politics, much like the market, is a cyclical process. In a two party system like we have, it is only a matter of time when the party on top slides back down. But after the last few elections brought about sweeping victories for the Democrats all around the nation could we be facing a prolonged period where Washington is dominated by one party? Or will the future bring about electoral success to the minority party?
First, it can't be overlooked the fact that the yoke of George W. Bush's legacy wrapped around the GOP necks was a large factor in explaining 2008 election defeats. It was evident for a few years that the Obama-Clinton primary winner would likely become the 44th President. The fact that the Democrats were able to rally the base around Obama and experience such large polling numbers further doomed the GOP. But the downward trend had become evident as far back as 2004 as the Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were slowly eating away at the approval figures for both the President and the GOP. But the up and down trend in American politics is proof that American voters are fickle. As the Bush legacy wanes into the sunset and the problems that plague America domestically with the economy, unemployment, and a more active federal government in our lives becomes more of an issue, Americans will look at the Democrats with a more discerning eye. Therefore, the GOP has an opportunity to regain some of their more recent losses.
But just as they have this opportunity, they must make some choices on who their leadership is, what they stand for, and present themselves as problem solvers. As of now, the average American voter has a growing disapproval with how the Democrats and President Obama have performed over the past year. But they also have not given the Republican party an attendant rise in approval. Instead, the average voter is basically saying, "I don't think either party is credible to handle these problems". Why this is so is simply that the GOP have spent the past year practicing parliamentary delays to slow the Dems down while offering only lip service to their tried and true values of low tax. small government priorities. The GOP of today is not the GOP of Barry Goldwater. There is a large untapped number of independents and libertarians who are just waiting for a reason to become involved at the political grass roots level. The Bush era Republicans allowed themselves to morph into a large spending, large deficit party that makes fiscal conservatives sick to their stomach. New leadership is needed and this leadership will have to make some tough choices on values and policy debates to change the course of direction for the GOP.
So as we look to 2010 and beyond, is it possible that we could be seeing a Democratic majority for the foreseeable future? I really believe that America works best under a divided government whereas one party controls Congress and the other- the White House. Before the Lewinsky scandal, the Clinton White House and GOP Congress scored major victories with the welfare reform and budget balancing measures. I think we could see a situation where Obama remains above that 50% popularity number and yet the Republicans make gains in Congress. But long term, the GOP is in a state of flux. They have not found their way back to the basic principles the party stood for and who the new breed of leaders will be is yet uncertain.
PERSONAL OPINION DISCLAIMER
I personally have lost faith in the Republican camp overall. Though they do field quality candidates in local races, the overall party has failed on their platform and have not handled the national debate very well over the most serious issues. Although my personal ideologies are more closely entwined with libertarian though, I also am a realist that recognizes that America is a 2 party state. The best way to bring about policy changes is to work within the system until that system ultimately allows a third party to compete for votes and minds.
First, it can't be overlooked the fact that the yoke of George W. Bush's legacy wrapped around the GOP necks was a large factor in explaining 2008 election defeats. It was evident for a few years that the Obama-Clinton primary winner would likely become the 44th President. The fact that the Democrats were able to rally the base around Obama and experience such large polling numbers further doomed the GOP. But the downward trend had become evident as far back as 2004 as the Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan were slowly eating away at the approval figures for both the President and the GOP. But the up and down trend in American politics is proof that American voters are fickle. As the Bush legacy wanes into the sunset and the problems that plague America domestically with the economy, unemployment, and a more active federal government in our lives becomes more of an issue, Americans will look at the Democrats with a more discerning eye. Therefore, the GOP has an opportunity to regain some of their more recent losses.
But just as they have this opportunity, they must make some choices on who their leadership is, what they stand for, and present themselves as problem solvers. As of now, the average American voter has a growing disapproval with how the Democrats and President Obama have performed over the past year. But they also have not given the Republican party an attendant rise in approval. Instead, the average voter is basically saying, "I don't think either party is credible to handle these problems". Why this is so is simply that the GOP have spent the past year practicing parliamentary delays to slow the Dems down while offering only lip service to their tried and true values of low tax. small government priorities. The GOP of today is not the GOP of Barry Goldwater. There is a large untapped number of independents and libertarians who are just waiting for a reason to become involved at the political grass roots level. The Bush era Republicans allowed themselves to morph into a large spending, large deficit party that makes fiscal conservatives sick to their stomach. New leadership is needed and this leadership will have to make some tough choices on values and policy debates to change the course of direction for the GOP.
So as we look to 2010 and beyond, is it possible that we could be seeing a Democratic majority for the foreseeable future? I really believe that America works best under a divided government whereas one party controls Congress and the other- the White House. Before the Lewinsky scandal, the Clinton White House and GOP Congress scored major victories with the welfare reform and budget balancing measures. I think we could see a situation where Obama remains above that 50% popularity number and yet the Republicans make gains in Congress. But long term, the GOP is in a state of flux. They have not found their way back to the basic principles the party stood for and who the new breed of leaders will be is yet uncertain.
PERSONAL OPINION DISCLAIMER
I personally have lost faith in the Republican camp overall. Though they do field quality candidates in local races, the overall party has failed on their platform and have not handled the national debate very well over the most serious issues. Although my personal ideologies are more closely entwined with libertarian though, I also am a realist that recognizes that America is a 2 party state. The best way to bring about policy changes is to work within the system until that system ultimately allows a third party to compete for votes and minds.
Monday, December 21, 2009
The discussion on health care
After criticism, Reid vindicated by early-morning healthcare vote - TheHill.com
The debate over health care reform took another step towards the final leg in what has been a very contentious battle. The Hill article cited above describes the leadership displayed by Senate Majority Leader Reid to get this through to a final vote. But I would argue that Reid and the Democratic majority in Congress are rushing through a final bill that will not truly reform the health care system and will also cause more financial burdens to the States. Where this reform is headed and what it means for the 2010 elections is open for discussion.
First, the bill that Reid and the Senate is pushing towards a final vote is far from the bill that the House members passed and what the liberal groups wanted. So will the House or Senate version make it out of the Conference? My personal feelings are-- neither. The health care reform that is needed is not necessarily a full blown overhaul of the entire system. Where the Democrats are failing on their efforts is that they overstepped what they thought the public wanted. A first step towards bringing about a needed change in health care is to open up different plans and options across state lines. Something like regional networks will introduce further 'competition' into a system that needs it without govt. intervention. Former presidential candidate Steve Forbes argued for just something like this in an interview on C-SPAN this week. Another small step that could be taken on behalf of Americans to deal with high costs is to allow medicines from Canada to be imported into American market to compete with higher cost medicines here in the U.S. Already, a growing number of seniors and those with high monthly medical treatments are finding ways around the system to do just that. Of course, as we have seen throughout the entire debate in Washington, pharmaceutical and insurance companies are using their $$ clout to insure that whatever passes Congress will not truly be reform. The Democrats and Republicans are now resorting to this issue of health care reform in an effort to score political points, not reform. But in the end I certainly see a bill that more closely resembles the Senate version but as just stated, will do little to deal with the symptoms that lead to high costs.
On a side note should be mentioned the fact that, like any other, insurance companies are a for-profit entity. Therefore, Americans should not be shocked that companies are making profits through the vehicle of premiums. I do feel it is healthy though to open up a debate on the issue of higher premiums and the use of coverage denials because of prior or pre-existing issues. Companies and the representatives in Congress should come to the table to discuss ways to cover more persons and keep premium increases to a minimum. But Democrats have also attempted to use this debate to paint insurance companies as inherently evil. As it stands it does look like the bill that would emerge from a conference committee will address premiums and pre-existing conditions but the final bill will not be the reform the liberal elitists wanted several months ago.
But this debate also brings up an interesting point. Is universal health care coverage a right guaranteed under federal law or a privilege that is open to all who choose to purchase insurance. For those advocating for universal coverage they would argue it is a right. Senator Harkin used this exact argument in his explanation for the need for reform while on the Senate floor last night. Yet the Preamble of the Constitution simply states,
“We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
In my understanding of the Constitution, nowhere does it provide the federal government with the power to force every American to have insurance. Health care coverage is for each person to decide for themselves and is no different than home ownership or any other lifestyle choice. Washington sees this as another opportunity to empower government at the expense of responsible Americans. The idea that the federal powers that be can make a better decision about my health care is laughable. What is needed are price controls in certain areas like medicines and premiums- but not universal coverage.
The debate over health care reform took another step towards the final leg in what has been a very contentious battle. The Hill article cited above describes the leadership displayed by Senate Majority Leader Reid to get this through to a final vote. But I would argue that Reid and the Democratic majority in Congress are rushing through a final bill that will not truly reform the health care system and will also cause more financial burdens to the States. Where this reform is headed and what it means for the 2010 elections is open for discussion.
First, the bill that Reid and the Senate is pushing towards a final vote is far from the bill that the House members passed and what the liberal groups wanted. So will the House or Senate version make it out of the Conference? My personal feelings are-- neither. The health care reform that is needed is not necessarily a full blown overhaul of the entire system. Where the Democrats are failing on their efforts is that they overstepped what they thought the public wanted. A first step towards bringing about a needed change in health care is to open up different plans and options across state lines. Something like regional networks will introduce further 'competition' into a system that needs it without govt. intervention. Former presidential candidate Steve Forbes argued for just something like this in an interview on C-SPAN this week. Another small step that could be taken on behalf of Americans to deal with high costs is to allow medicines from Canada to be imported into American market to compete with higher cost medicines here in the U.S. Already, a growing number of seniors and those with high monthly medical treatments are finding ways around the system to do just that. Of course, as we have seen throughout the entire debate in Washington, pharmaceutical and insurance companies are using their $$ clout to insure that whatever passes Congress will not truly be reform. The Democrats and Republicans are now resorting to this issue of health care reform in an effort to score political points, not reform. But in the end I certainly see a bill that more closely resembles the Senate version but as just stated, will do little to deal with the symptoms that lead to high costs.
On a side note should be mentioned the fact that, like any other, insurance companies are a for-profit entity. Therefore, Americans should not be shocked that companies are making profits through the vehicle of premiums. I do feel it is healthy though to open up a debate on the issue of higher premiums and the use of coverage denials because of prior or pre-existing issues. Companies and the representatives in Congress should come to the table to discuss ways to cover more persons and keep premium increases to a minimum. But Democrats have also attempted to use this debate to paint insurance companies as inherently evil. As it stands it does look like the bill that would emerge from a conference committee will address premiums and pre-existing conditions but the final bill will not be the reform the liberal elitists wanted several months ago.
But this debate also brings up an interesting point. Is universal health care coverage a right guaranteed under federal law or a privilege that is open to all who choose to purchase insurance. For those advocating for universal coverage they would argue it is a right. Senator Harkin used this exact argument in his explanation for the need for reform while on the Senate floor last night. Yet the Preamble of the Constitution simply states,
“We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
In my understanding of the Constitution, nowhere does it provide the federal government with the power to force every American to have insurance. Health care coverage is for each person to decide for themselves and is no different than home ownership or any other lifestyle choice. Washington sees this as another opportunity to empower government at the expense of responsible Americans. The idea that the federal powers that be can make a better decision about my health care is laughable. What is needed are price controls in certain areas like medicines and premiums- but not universal coverage.
Friday, April 17, 2009
Patriotic Dissent
Patriotism is defined as love of and/or devotion to one's country. The word comes from the Greek patris. Hillary Clinton last year used a previously quoted phrase when she stated that, "dissent is the highest form of patriotism". Indeed- the great thing about America and our rich history is the fact that we have Constitutional rights to meet together and speak out in criticism against our government (conveniently forgetting about Adams and his Sedition Act). That is exactly what took place on April 15th when Americans gathered to speak out about the size, scope, and waste of our governments both at the state and federal level.
The nationwide tea parties enabled every American to voice their concerns over the state of affairs in Washington. It isn't an attack personally on Obama. It's a wake up call to every public official. Unfortunately the problems highlighted by the nationwide rallies (the pork, the bailouts , taxes, etc.) were a result of too long a period of complacency. The nation was founded on principles of limited government and an ethic of personal responsibility. Today we have a government bloated by bureaucracy and generations of leaders unwilling to make difficult choices to limit the growing power of Washington. Instead of sunsetting agencies and programs, they were allowed to become a permanent establishment that now eats up a significant portion of our budget each year (and yes I am speaking of Medicare, Social Security, etc).
Americans are fed to believe that their government is a benevolent hand leading all towards equal opportunities for success and grow up in an era not of personal responsibility, but of personal entitlement! When those values eroded and our government grew and grew it became harder and harder to erase those programs. Now the current Administration wants to throw more money at problems that aren't simply about money. At the root of it- it is about RESPONSIBILITY. The responsibility of our government to be more accountable to the constituents, the responsibility of leaders and business executives to be fiscally sound. Not taking risks with investments, mortgages, accounts, etc. on the backs of those they do business for, and a personal responsibility from all of us to take into account the well being of our own lives, our own families, and our own communities. A great quote by Confucius states this clearly,
"To put the world right in order, we must first put the nation in order; to put the nation in order, we must first put the family in order; to put the family in order, we must first cultivate our personal life; we must first set our hearts right."
~ Confucius
With that being said we can only hope that the April 15th showing from every corner of our nation is just the first example of Americans taking part in 'patriotic dissent' to place this needed debate at the forefront of the national conscience.
The nationwide tea parties enabled every American to voice their concerns over the state of affairs in Washington. It isn't an attack personally on Obama. It's a wake up call to every public official. Unfortunately the problems highlighted by the nationwide rallies (the pork, the bailouts , taxes, etc.) were a result of too long a period of complacency. The nation was founded on principles of limited government and an ethic of personal responsibility. Today we have a government bloated by bureaucracy and generations of leaders unwilling to make difficult choices to limit the growing power of Washington. Instead of sunsetting agencies and programs, they were allowed to become a permanent establishment that now eats up a significant portion of our budget each year (and yes I am speaking of Medicare, Social Security, etc).
Americans are fed to believe that their government is a benevolent hand leading all towards equal opportunities for success and grow up in an era not of personal responsibility, but of personal entitlement! When those values eroded and our government grew and grew it became harder and harder to erase those programs. Now the current Administration wants to throw more money at problems that aren't simply about money. At the root of it- it is about RESPONSIBILITY. The responsibility of our government to be more accountable to the constituents, the responsibility of leaders and business executives to be fiscally sound. Not taking risks with investments, mortgages, accounts, etc. on the backs of those they do business for, and a personal responsibility from all of us to take into account the well being of our own lives, our own families, and our own communities. A great quote by Confucius states this clearly,
"To put the world right in order, we must first put the nation in order; to put the nation in order, we must first put the family in order; to put the family in order, we must first cultivate our personal life; we must first set our hearts right."
~ Confucius
With that being said we can only hope that the April 15th showing from every corner of our nation is just the first example of Americans taking part in 'patriotic dissent' to place this needed debate at the forefront of the national conscience.
Wednesday, March 11, 2009
First 50 Days and on....
President Obama campaigned on change and a new way of governing. The promises being thrown out sounded good and Americans supported that call. Yet we have now been able to follow his Presidency for almost 2 months now and it appears that promises are one thing-- keeping your word is quite another.
First- Then-candidate Obama pledged that earmarks or pork projects would end with his taking office. Yet, the statement coming from his office today proves otherwise-- http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=101728951. By signing H.R. 1105 FY 2009 Omnibus Appropriations Act, Obama is showing that the 'change' he discussed during his campaign was not really change at all. It is more of the same. Gone are the days when spending bills went the normal route for each agency and were publicly debated and then agreed to SEPARATELY. The earmarks that were once a problem will continue being problematic until our chief executive takes a stand and vetoes those spending bills, emergency or not.
Congress is also to blame. Partisanship in Washington is just as bad now as it was at the height of the Bush Administration. Obama also pledged to work with Republicans but that was little more than window dressing as his dominions in the House and Senate leadership continue to shoot down any Amendment offered to the spending and bailout bills that came up before Congress. In fact, it was widely known that no single Republican voted for his recent bailout plan simply b/c no real effort was attempted to meet Republican ideas halfway.
It appears now that the only positive effects of the recent election of Obama is that the opposition has now begun to rally around the cause of less government and less regulation. Unfortunately, these members were nowhere to be found while former President Bush was laying waste to the conservative agenda. It will take new voices, new leadership and working together for the conservative/libertarian voices to bring about the 'change' needed. Obama was on the right track with his campaign speeches and pledges...the problem lies with action. And thus far- Obama's actions are speaking louder than his words.
First- Then-candidate Obama pledged that earmarks or pork projects would end with his taking office. Yet, the statement coming from his office today proves otherwise-- http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=101728951. By signing H.R. 1105 FY 2009 Omnibus Appropriations Act, Obama is showing that the 'change' he discussed during his campaign was not really change at all. It is more of the same. Gone are the days when spending bills went the normal route for each agency and were publicly debated and then agreed to SEPARATELY. The earmarks that were once a problem will continue being problematic until our chief executive takes a stand and vetoes those spending bills, emergency or not.
Congress is also to blame. Partisanship in Washington is just as bad now as it was at the height of the Bush Administration. Obama also pledged to work with Republicans but that was little more than window dressing as his dominions in the House and Senate leadership continue to shoot down any Amendment offered to the spending and bailout bills that came up before Congress. In fact, it was widely known that no single Republican voted for his recent bailout plan simply b/c no real effort was attempted to meet Republican ideas halfway.
It appears now that the only positive effects of the recent election of Obama is that the opposition has now begun to rally around the cause of less government and less regulation. Unfortunately, these members were nowhere to be found while former President Bush was laying waste to the conservative agenda. It will take new voices, new leadership and working together for the conservative/libertarian voices to bring about the 'change' needed. Obama was on the right track with his campaign speeches and pledges...the problem lies with action. And thus far- Obama's actions are speaking louder than his words.
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Bailouts & Handouts
In an article published in today's Washington Times, http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/dec/09/15-billion-auto-bailout-goes-to-white-house/, it appears as if some form of a small scale bailout will be doled out to the Big 3 automakers. This in advance of a more likely large scale bailout plan in the future once Obama takes office. There is no doubt that many companies are hurting in this economic climate. But what might these longer term effects be of all of our "handouts" to the various companies thus far and are we certain that these very companies can build a successful plan to keep them financially secure in the future??
First off, there is the fear of the automakers becoming a liability along the scale of Amtrak. Amtrak being the company that fell on tough financial times and were then basically subsidized through federal monies every fiscal year. We cannot afford these kinds of 'gifts' in this economy. We are facing very serious decisions that will be painful in the short term but must be made if we are to regain long term financial solvency -- trade deficits, entitlement programs, the market, etc.. That is why we must first make a decision about what kind of economy ours should be. It is becoming painfully clear that the new leadership in Congress would like to steer us away from a market based, capitalist system towards one of increased regulation and more centralized control and planning of our major sectors.
Wikipedia defines capitalism as: an economic system in which capital goods are owned, operated and traded chiefly by private individuals or corporations for the purpose of profit, with the state confined in providing some public goods and infrastructure.[1] In a capitalist system, private control of these productive enterprises is protected by the rule of law and a regulatory framework.[2] A capitalist political system protects the exchange and distribution of capital between legal or private persons, which is driven by competition and profit-maximization,[3][4] and where investments, distribution, income, production and pricing of goods, commodities and services are predominantly determined through the operation of a market economy[5] in which anyone can participate in supply and demand and form contracts with anyone else, rather than by central economic planning.
If we are truly a capitalist society then where does the bailout/handout end and tough love begin? How do we decide which companies will qualify for an assistance package and which do not? Those are necessary to answer before we go down this slippery slope.
Here is what I believe should be done. First, make these bailouts a one-time, short term grant/loan. This can help us eliminate the fear that these companies can still fail and come back for more handouts. Secondly, appoint a group of economic advisers and advisers familiar with these industries who can force each company to make concessions and reforms that may hurt short term such as job losses, short term financial losses, etc.. but will place them on very good ground for future growth. Finally, we need to focus on a total makeover of our domestic economy. We are faced with terror threats and problems on the international level but we must focus on our own domestic needs for the first few years and maybe first term of the Obama Administration. Say what you will about the Bush Presidency but the focus he placed on international terror has kept us relatively safe but at the expense of an economy now in recession while billions and billions were spent in Iraq. It may be time we place the majority of the security and governing burden upon the Iraqis (with maybe military advisers for training, etc. much like what we now have in Korea). Then we can scale back the spending that goes towards that and instead place it back into investments for our own economy. But one thing is clear, the bailouts cannot last forever and I believe people will slowly realize that capitalism is not the enemy, poor leadership at the highest levels of these companies are the ones to blame. It's a tough world and survival of the fitttest means not every one will make it. These companies MUST adapt or be left on their own.
First off, there is the fear of the automakers becoming a liability along the scale of Amtrak. Amtrak being the company that fell on tough financial times and were then basically subsidized through federal monies every fiscal year. We cannot afford these kinds of 'gifts' in this economy. We are facing very serious decisions that will be painful in the short term but must be made if we are to regain long term financial solvency -- trade deficits, entitlement programs, the market, etc.. That is why we must first make a decision about what kind of economy ours should be. It is becoming painfully clear that the new leadership in Congress would like to steer us away from a market based, capitalist system towards one of increased regulation and more centralized control and planning of our major sectors.
Wikipedia defines capitalism as: an economic system in which capital goods are owned, operated and traded chiefly by private individuals or corporations for the purpose of profit, with the state confined in providing some public goods and infrastructure.[1] In a capitalist system, private control of these productive enterprises is protected by the rule of law and a regulatory framework.[2] A capitalist political system protects the exchange and distribution of capital between legal or private persons, which is driven by competition and profit-maximization,[3][4] and where investments, distribution, income, production and pricing of goods, commodities and services are predominantly determined through the operation of a market economy[5] in which anyone can participate in supply and demand and form contracts with anyone else, rather than by central economic planning.
If we are truly a capitalist society then where does the bailout/handout end and tough love begin? How do we decide which companies will qualify for an assistance package and which do not? Those are necessary to answer before we go down this slippery slope.
Here is what I believe should be done. First, make these bailouts a one-time, short term grant/loan. This can help us eliminate the fear that these companies can still fail and come back for more handouts. Secondly, appoint a group of economic advisers and advisers familiar with these industries who can force each company to make concessions and reforms that may hurt short term such as job losses, short term financial losses, etc.. but will place them on very good ground for future growth. Finally, we need to focus on a total makeover of our domestic economy. We are faced with terror threats and problems on the international level but we must focus on our own domestic needs for the first few years and maybe first term of the Obama Administration. Say what you will about the Bush Presidency but the focus he placed on international terror has kept us relatively safe but at the expense of an economy now in recession while billions and billions were spent in Iraq. It may be time we place the majority of the security and governing burden upon the Iraqis (with maybe military advisers for training, etc. much like what we now have in Korea). Then we can scale back the spending that goes towards that and instead place it back into investments for our own economy. But one thing is clear, the bailouts cannot last forever and I believe people will slowly realize that capitalism is not the enemy, poor leadership at the highest levels of these companies are the ones to blame. It's a tough world and survival of the fitttest means not every one will make it. These companies MUST adapt or be left on their own.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)