Sunday, June 3, 2007

Middle East Volatility

The violence in Iraq confronting the U.S. forces has a much deeper root in history than most liberals want you to think. According to Rep. Murtha this morning, troop presence is the overwhelming reason for the suicide attacks and Al-Qaeda sympathizers inside Iraq. A deeper understanding of the region is necessary for the debate on Iraq and possible solutions to the Middle East conflicts.

Much of the borders separating the countries within the Middle East were arbitrarily set up by Western diplomats and followed no real cultural or historical basis. Thus, these areas were ripe for nationalist movements from the very beginning and further fueled by Western leaders' efforts to influence the economic and political development of the region. At the end of WWI, the leaders of the victorious allies set up the region to best suit their needs and state interests.

Then came the forced establishment of Israel amidst the various Arab nations. We can support Israel all we want but we must understand the effects Israel's creation had on the minds of the Arab people. They view Israel as a Western creation in order to have more and more influence over Middle Eastern affairs. No matter what diplomatic efforts or overtures are presented, we can reasonably conclude that a majority of the Middle East opposes Israel's very existence and will covertly attempt its downfall.

Understanding these factors will finally enable us to approach reasonable compromises and ideas to settle the unrest. First of all, pulling out troops from Iraq is not the simple answer. Decades of Western peddling in the region will not be cured by a sudden pull-out. Along with a downsizing of troop presence, the United States along with various NGO's and world bodies need to study the infrastructures of these societies. Removing poverty and forcing these nations leaders to focus on internal issues will allow their societies a stronger foundation to thrive in the future. But these approaches are also based on 2 major compromises needed from both sides. The Arab/Muslin nations of the Middle East must recognize Israel's existence and explore ways to turn this fact into economic benefits through trade pacts, etc..
Also, the West must come to grips with the fact that implanting our view of democracy will only cause more upheaval. We must allow the region to set up it's own form of government short of tyranny and dictatorship. Through the U.N., we can insist that certain guarantees are met-- freedom of speech and other personal freedoms. But our form of democracy isn't necessarily a one-size-fits-all.

The political rhetoric coming from both sides hides the fact that both sides have legitimate ideas. Through an understanding of the region's past, we can begin to truly make the hard decisions necessary to reaching peace in the Middle East.

No comments: