Wednesday, July 11, 2007

Senate Iraq Debate

In what is only a renewed debate on the heated topic of the Iraq War, Dems and an increasing number of Republicans are renewing its offensive against the Administration's handling of the Iraq War. I have a few feelings on this current debate. First, I think the new efforts by the Senate are heading in the right direction. Yet, it's a bit premature in so far as they only a few months ago gave their support to Gen. David Petraeus for the new offensive strategy to be implemented. It is certainly debatable as to what the outcome of this offensive has been, but it is also clear that the Senate have not given sufficient time to allow the commanders in the field to implement the plans and then report back on the outcome. I also have concerns about where the power lies in regards to military command and strategy. The Constitution clearly assigns the President as Commander-in-Chief of the military which is delegated then to the Pentagon and its individual commanders. In 1861, Lincoln faced the problem of leading the North's war efforts in the midst of a vocal Congress about the War's management. It is the President's decision alone as to how and when the military is used in conflict.

But with all of that being said- I am joining the Congress in holding the debate in the national spotlight so that it is clear to both the White House and the Pentagon, that they must begin discussing a drastic new approach in Iraq. The Iraqi government has proven its incapability to resolve the pressing issues required of a government. Their task is certainly difficult with so many divergent constituencies and operating in a country torn by chaos and insecurity. Yet, we need to send a clear message by developing a new strategy. One that begins a phased withdrawal beginning by January of 2008 of most of the current divisions. Redeploy the remaining troops in a more fruitful manner, i.e. training Iraqi troops and police and use our troops as a counter terrorist force. In the end, it is not Congress that should make these decisions though. The orders must come from the White House and top military advisers. The separation of powers issue has gotten so murky and been abused so often, that Americans themselves don't realize which branch holds what powers.

One thing is clear- Iraq needs to become an issue for Iraqi's (with international support on terror, border security, etc..) to begin solving. Senate Republicans know that if a phased withdrawal by the end of the year or first part of next year is adopted, they can regain momentum leading up to the elections. Though debate on the war is beneficial to all of us concerned with America's security, the United States Senate needs to refocus its energies on solving other critical matters that fall to their Constitutional powers.

No comments: