Friday, November 9, 2007

Polls Polls Polls

I don't know what the rest of America believes on the subject of polls, but I am thoroughly sick of seeing a new article on 'recent polls suggest..' in every major newspaper. Every week we read headlines about who the frontrunner is, who would win if..., what issues are more important. It is imperative people look at polling critically.

First of all, polls aren't infallible and are subject to human error. Pollsters have to make assumptions based on their interviews with a small segment of society. Can 5,000 people responding really ascertain how the entire nation feels on domestic and foreign issues? Also, there is always the possibility that respondents will not be completely true in their answers. A great example of this is the exit polling early in the evening during the 2004 Presidential election. If you took the results for truth, Kerry would have won the election by 15 points.

Secondly, we must look to see who is sponsoring the polls. Hidden agendas are just the truth when it comes to newspaper editorial boards, journalists, and other "independent" sources. Often times these persons are cunning in that they want a certain issue or candidate to come out of the polling in a positive light. Therefore, the weekly polls that we see now, a full year before elections , should be taken with a discerning eye.

Thirdly, polling ruins the possible greatness of the campaign process. Our campaign process is already broken because of money and finance reform fallacies. Money runs campaigns. Now, with the onset of polling data and figures (whether they are correct or not in its result) tends to eliminate any shot for independent minded candidates. If you have less money or are not part of the power center of either major party, negative polling hampers the possibility of correcting early campaign slumps. I can guarantee (although I don't have the figures in front of me) that every election cycle brings about thousands of voters who vote for someone simply b/c they are a frontrunner. Why? Because the candidate they prefer is no longer viable.

My suggestions are this. Public media needs to be limited to what kind of polling is done and what figures are published. It is certainly an aid when an official wants to know what issues are most important to their constituencies. But having a head to head poll before the parties and voters have a chance to select their candidates is ludicrous.
Also, exit polling should be disallowed. Voters are uncomfortable revealing their votes as it is. Having cameras and reporters hound them upon leaving the voting booth is unfair. Plus, as discussed, is it reliable. People in California, Oregon, Colorado, etc... are bombarded with who is leading in the polls hours before their precincts are closed.

In short- polling is a fruitless hobby amongst political junkies. It's amusing that our politics has come to this.

No comments: