In an article published in today's Washington Times, http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2008/dec/09/15-billion-auto-bailout-goes-to-white-house/, it appears as if some form of a small scale bailout will be doled out to the Big 3 automakers. This in advance of a more likely large scale bailout plan in the future once Obama takes office. There is no doubt that many companies are hurting in this economic climate. But what might these longer term effects be of all of our "handouts" to the various companies thus far and are we certain that these very companies can build a successful plan to keep them financially secure in the future??
First off, there is the fear of the automakers becoming a liability along the scale of Amtrak. Amtrak being the company that fell on tough financial times and were then basically subsidized through federal monies every fiscal year. We cannot afford these kinds of 'gifts' in this economy. We are facing very serious decisions that will be painful in the short term but must be made if we are to regain long term financial solvency -- trade deficits, entitlement programs, the market, etc.. That is why we must first make a decision about what kind of economy ours should be. It is becoming painfully clear that the new leadership in Congress would like to steer us away from a market based, capitalist system towards one of increased regulation and more centralized control and planning of our major sectors.
Wikipedia defines capitalism as: an economic system in which capital goods are owned, operated and traded chiefly by private individuals or corporations for the purpose of profit, with the state confined in providing some public goods and infrastructure.[1] In a capitalist system, private control of these productive enterprises is protected by the rule of law and a regulatory framework.[2] A capitalist political system protects the exchange and distribution of capital between legal or private persons, which is driven by competition and profit-maximization,[3][4] and where investments, distribution, income, production and pricing of goods, commodities and services are predominantly determined through the operation of a market economy[5] in which anyone can participate in supply and demand and form contracts with anyone else, rather than by central economic planning.
If we are truly a capitalist society then where does the bailout/handout end and tough love begin? How do we decide which companies will qualify for an assistance package and which do not? Those are necessary to answer before we go down this slippery slope.
Here is what I believe should be done. First, make these bailouts a one-time, short term grant/loan. This can help us eliminate the fear that these companies can still fail and come back for more handouts. Secondly, appoint a group of economic advisers and advisers familiar with these industries who can force each company to make concessions and reforms that may hurt short term such as job losses, short term financial losses, etc.. but will place them on very good ground for future growth. Finally, we need to focus on a total makeover of our domestic economy. We are faced with terror threats and problems on the international level but we must focus on our own domestic needs for the first few years and maybe first term of the Obama Administration. Say what you will about the Bush Presidency but the focus he placed on international terror has kept us relatively safe but at the expense of an economy now in recession while billions and billions were spent in Iraq. It may be time we place the majority of the security and governing burden upon the Iraqis (with maybe military advisers for training, etc. much like what we now have in Korea). Then we can scale back the spending that goes towards that and instead place it back into investments for our own economy. But one thing is clear, the bailouts cannot last forever and I believe people will slowly realize that capitalism is not the enemy, poor leadership at the highest levels of these companies are the ones to blame. It's a tough world and survival of the fitttest means not every one will make it. These companies MUST adapt or be left on their own.
No comments:
Post a Comment