After criticism, Reid vindicated by early-morning healthcare vote - TheHill.com
The debate over health care reform took another step towards the final leg in what has been a very contentious battle. The Hill article cited above describes the leadership displayed by Senate Majority Leader Reid to get this through to a final vote. But I would argue that Reid and the Democratic majority in Congress are rushing through a final bill that will not truly reform the health care system and will also cause more financial burdens to the States. Where this reform is headed and what it means for the 2010 elections is open for discussion.
First, the bill that Reid and the Senate is pushing towards a final vote is far from the bill that the House members passed and what the liberal groups wanted. So will the House or Senate version make it out of the Conference? My personal feelings are-- neither. The health care reform that is needed is not necessarily a full blown overhaul of the entire system. Where the Democrats are failing on their efforts is that they overstepped what they thought the public wanted. A first step towards bringing about a needed change in health care is to open up different plans and options across state lines. Something like regional networks will introduce further 'competition' into a system that needs it without govt. intervention. Former presidential candidate Steve Forbes argued for just something like this in an interview on C-SPAN this week. Another small step that could be taken on behalf of Americans to deal with high costs is to allow medicines from Canada to be imported into American market to compete with higher cost medicines here in the U.S. Already, a growing number of seniors and those with high monthly medical treatments are finding ways around the system to do just that. Of course, as we have seen throughout the entire debate in Washington, pharmaceutical and insurance companies are using their $$ clout to insure that whatever passes Congress will not truly be reform. The Democrats and Republicans are now resorting to this issue of health care reform in an effort to score political points, not reform. But in the end I certainly see a bill that more closely resembles the Senate version but as just stated, will do little to deal with the symptoms that lead to high costs.
On a side note should be mentioned the fact that, like any other, insurance companies are a for-profit entity. Therefore, Americans should not be shocked that companies are making profits through the vehicle of premiums. I do feel it is healthy though to open up a debate on the issue of higher premiums and the use of coverage denials because of prior or pre-existing issues. Companies and the representatives in Congress should come to the table to discuss ways to cover more persons and keep premium increases to a minimum. But Democrats have also attempted to use this debate to paint insurance companies as inherently evil. As it stands it does look like the bill that would emerge from a conference committee will address premiums and pre-existing conditions but the final bill will not be the reform the liberal elitists wanted several months ago.
But this debate also brings up an interesting point. Is universal health care coverage a right guaranteed under federal law or a privilege that is open to all who choose to purchase insurance. For those advocating for universal coverage they would argue it is a right. Senator Harkin used this exact argument in his explanation for the need for reform while on the Senate floor last night. Yet the Preamble of the Constitution simply states,
“We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
In my understanding of the Constitution, nowhere does it provide the federal government with the power to force every American to have insurance. Health care coverage is for each person to decide for themselves and is no different than home ownership or any other lifestyle choice. Washington sees this as another opportunity to empower government at the expense of responsible Americans. The idea that the federal powers that be can make a better decision about my health care is laughable. What is needed are price controls in certain areas like medicines and premiums- but not universal coverage.
No comments:
Post a Comment