Monday, May 9, 2011

Budget Battle Ahead

In recent weeks the issue concerning the U.S. debt ceiling has taken center stage. Whether this show down develops into a Democratic President vs. Republican Congress type battle (ala 1996 Clinton-Gingrich) will depend a lot on the next month or so. We have heard from the main stream media and Obama officials on why this really is a no-brainer. We absolutely have to raise the debt ceiling. They predict government failure and financial Armageddon if the Republicans in the House take a firm stand. But let's take a closer look at this issue.

First, is an article by D.W. MacKenzie on the Mises website, The Budget Mess: Time to Get Serious. MacKenzie makes many valid points but the thrust of his argument is simply this-- WE WONT DEFAULT IF WE REFUSE TO RAISE THE CEILING! It's an old tactic used by both parties where you scare your opposition into submission or at least a tacit compromise to accomplish your goal. In fact going back to the last years of the George W. Bush era through now, our fiscal discipline in Washington has gone from laughable to just plain ignoring basic economic common sense. In years past, all financial backbone has disappeared from Congress and the President and debt ceilings are raised on whims and spending continues to escalate to alarming levels. Why this happens is simple. Congress is elected by the people. The people grow fat and accustomed to government programs and handouts. So these officials have incentives to print more money, spend more money, and ignore long term public interest-- financial stability. But back to the debt ceiling. The Treasury Dept has not already spent the money that the debt ceiling is meant to control. It's simply set a trajectory level for forecasting purposes. So by holding firm and refusing to raise that ceiling, we basically force Congress and Obama's hand. We simply alter their spending whims and wants.

But more than the financial jargon that gets passed around for why we can't or can raise the debt ceiling, it is a moral issue as to why we shouldn't. It's dishonest for Congress to continue to approve budgets and programs that are beyond our means to pay for. We can only spend out in government programs and agencies what the Treasury brings in via tax receipts. It would appear to be a simply Econ 101 lesson. Surprisingly- this is lost on Geithner, Obama, and others who follow Keynesian basic precepts. Political self-interest should not outweigh long term financial stability of the U.S. Our leaders have known for decades that the entitlement programs that were enacted during FDR and then in LBJ periods were not doable over the long term unless changes were formulated. Entitlement under-funding to go along with an outrageous federal debt is a combination that will only injure the U.S credit market and force even more painful concessions later down the road. We have an opportunity now to be straight with Americans regardless of how they take it. Let's hope the debt ceiling issue forces that debate out into the open.

No comments: